When mixing cocktails, choosing the right shaker can make all the difference. If you’re new to the art of mixing cocktails, you may have stumbled across the terms Boston shaker and the cobbler shaker. These are the two most popular options when it comes to cocktail shakers. But what are the differences between the Boston shaker and the cobbler shaker? Each has its own unique features, advantages, and style. In this post, we’ll explore the Boston shaker vs. cobbler shaker, helping you determine which is the best fit for your bartending needs.
What is a Boston Shaker?
The Boston shaker consists of two pieces: a metal tin and a mixing glass or another tin. This shaker is a favorite among professional bartenders for several reasons. The tin+glass variety allows for viewing of the drink as it’s shaken to ensure all ingredients are mixed while the tin+tin variety provides more durability.
Advantages of the Boston Shaker
- Size: The Boston shaker can accommodate larger quantities of ingredients, making it ideal for batch cocktails.
- Durability: Made from stainless steel, it’s resistant to rust and can withstand the rigors of a busy bar environment.
- Easy Separation: The two-piece design results in less binding after shaking, which means less mess and a quicker workflow.
Disadvantages of the Boston Shaker
- Strainer Not Included: You’ll need to purchase a separate strainer to keep your ice out of the pour.
- Glass: If you opt for the tin+glass variety, you will need to be careful not to break the glass.
Ideal for:
Professional bartenders or home enthusiasts who prefer a sleek, minimalistic approach to cocktail making.
Recommended Boston Shaker
Cocktail Kingdom Leopold Weighted Shaking Tin Set
What is a Cobbler Shaker?
The cobbler shaker, on the other hand, typically features three pieces: a metal tin, a lid with a built-in strainer, and a cap. This shaker is often more beginner-friendly but may limit the quality of the final drink and progression to the next level of bartending skills.
Advantages of the Cobbler Shaker
- Built-in Strainer: The integrated strainer simplifies the pouring process, making it easier for beginners.
- Aesthetic Appeal: Many cobbler shakers come in stylish designs, perfect for display in your home bar.
- User-Friendly: The three-piece design is intuitive, making it easy for anyone to start shaking cocktails right away.
Disadvantages of the Cobbler Shaker
- Size: Most cobbler shakers are smaller in size than their Boston shaker counterparts limiting the number of drinks that can be built to just one.
- Binding: Because the tin contracts as a result of the cold ice, separating the tin from the lid to start a new cocktail can be difficult. A cobbler shaker with less contact surface may reduce binding.
- Leaking: Cobbler shakers, especially lower-quality ones, tend to have less of a seal between the lid and the cap. This can result in leaking.
Ideal for:
Casual home bartenders or those who appreciate a stylish, easy-to-use shaker.
Recommended Cobbler Shaker
Cocktail Kingdom Usagi Heavyweight Cobbler Shaker
Key Differences: Boston Shaker vs. Cobbler Shaker
| Feature | Boston Shaker | Cobbler Shaker |
|---|---|---|
| Pieces | 2 (tin + glass/tin) | 3 (tin + lid + cap) |
| Strainer | None (requires separate strainer) | Built-in strainer |
| Capacity | Larger capacity | Smaller capacity |
| Ease of Use | Requires practice | User-friendly |
| Durability | Highly durable | Generally durable |
Which Shaker Should You Choose?
Consider Your Experience Level
- Beginners: If you’re new to mixology, the cobbler shaker may be the better choice. Its user-friendly design makes it easy to get started.
- Experienced Bartenders: If you’re looking for versatility and efficiency, the Boston shaker is likely the way to go. Its larger capacity and faster workflow make it a staple in professional settings.
Consider Your Style
- Aesthetic Appeal: If the look of your barware matters to you, cobbler shakers come in various designs that can add a touch of elegance to your setup.
- Minimalism: If you prefer a sleek and simple design, the Boston shaker fits the bill perfectly.
Conclusion
Both the Boston shaker and cobbler shaker have their own merits, and the best choice ultimately depends on your personal preferences and mixing style. Whether you’re a seasoned bartender or just starting your cocktail journey, understanding the differences can help you create the perfect drinks for any occasion.
Check out this great video from Common Man Cocktails for more great insights.
Featured Image Designed by Freepik
Essential Bar Tools
Shaker
Jigger
Strainer
